Classification & Causation

22 important questions on Classification & Causation

What kind of factors can cause mental disorders?

  • biological factors (e.g., genetics, brain anatomy, brain chemistry, hormones, genetics, evolution, etc.)

  • psychological factors (e.g., psychodynamic, behavioural, cognitive, humanistic-existential, etc.)


  • environmental factors (e.g., social labels and roles, SES, social interactions, family structure, etc

What is the diathesis-stress model?

Introduced by Zubin & Spring (1977) as a way to account for multiple cause of schizophrenia


---> Diathesis = Predisposition/vulnerability toward developing a disorder (a diathesis can be inherited)
---> Other diatheses: oxygen deprivation at birth, cognitive set, poor nutrition, intense fear of becoming fat.   ---> stressful conditions needed as trigger
---> Since late 1980s, focus on protective factors (warm/supportive family environment, high self-esteem, school achievement, etc.) - in attempt to stop the development of schizophrenia (p. 77 - 79 abnormal textbook)

What does early trauma lead to?

Early trauma (e.g. being separated from mother) results in elevated activity in the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis when exposed to stressor later in life (animal studies).

(see slide 5, p. 5 lecture notes for diagram)
  • Higher grades + faster learning
  • Never study anything twice
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Discover Study Smart

What do the adrenal glands produce?

Stress hormones e.g. adrenaline, dopamine and cortisol

What does cortisol and adrenaline do?

  • Cortisol = raises the sugar in the bloodstream and prepares the body for fight or flight response
  • Adrenaline = raises heart rate and increases blood pressure

Who developed the first classification system?

Emil Kraepelin in 1883

What are the classification systems?

  • Diagnostic Statistical Manual (DSM, APA)
---> the DSM specifies what subtypes of mental disorders are officially recognised, and provides a set of defining criteria
  • International Classification of Diseases (ICD, WHO)


(p. 142 abnormal textbook)

What are 5 advantages and 3 disadvantages of classifying mental disorders?

Advantages:
  • Nomenclature (a naming system)
  • Allows to structure information
  • Allows research
  • Allows to develop (and generalise) treatment
  • Multicultural - same diagnosis all around the world


Disadvantages:

  • Loss of (idiosyncratic) information
  • Stigma, Stereotyping & Discrimination
  • Problem of labelling / Self concept is affected

What are the 2 categories of mental disorders?

Psychosis = person experiences serious distortion of perception and thought that weaken their grasp on reality, severe.

Neurosis = person still in touch with reality, less severe, now anxiety disorders (defined in terms of observable features such as excessive anxiety in general or in a particular setting

What are 2 other factors that may be relevant in causing mental disorders?

Ethnicity and culture

e.g. anxiety disorders are particularly high in the US
(see slide 1, p. 7 lecture notes, for table full of examples)  

(the DSM-IV-TR takes these factors into account)

How does the DSM-IV-TR enhance cultural sensitivity?

  • by providing a general framework for evaluating the role of culture and ethnicity
  • by describing cultural factors and ethnicity for each disorder
  • by listing cultural-bound syndromes in an appendix

Why is it important to take cultural backgrounds into account when classifying mental disorders?

The patients ethnicity and cultural background, level of English language comprehension, religious background can result in incorrect diagnosis.

People who have not been acculturated to the environment in which they live can appear more psychologically disturbed on tests and interviews than they really are (Okazaki et al., 2009)

---> advantage of the DSM-IV-TR

(p. 144 abnormal textbook)

When can a diagnosis be classed as accurate?

If they allow accurate predictions
(e.g. Major Depression and symptoms of insomnia)

What are key changes to the DSM-V in 2013?

A few examples:

  • Adding a new category: “mixed anxiety/depression” ---> this is a relatively common disorder
  • Adding new grouping: “substance use and addictive disorders” (adding non-substance disorders)
  • Adding a new category, “binge eating disorder”
  • Removing the category “obsessive-compulsive disorder” under the grouping called “obsessive-compulsive and related disorders”
  • Changing the definition of personality disorders
  • Only 6 (instead of 10) personality disorders: antisocial, avoidant, borderline, narcissistic, obsessive-compulsive, and schizotypal
  • Adding a new category, “autism spectrum disorder” (ASD) (Asperger -> autism)
  • Eliminating DSM-IV schizophrenia subcategories: paranoid, disorganized, catatonic, undifferentiated, residual

What can be said about the European system on the classification of mental disorders?

  • ICD-10, published by World Health Organization
  • Differs from DSM-IV-TR on criteria
  • Only transient tic disorder is identical in both systems!


(main categories on slide 4, p. 8 lecture slides)

How can labelling effect treatment choices?

A diagnosis such as "persistent depressive disorder" may cut off and further inquiry about the patient's life situation and lead abruptly to a prescription for antidepressant medication

(p. 144 abnormal textbook)

How can labelling affect the diagnosed person?

They may feel that they have to play out the expectations of that role

(p. 144 abnormal textbook)

Can diagnosis and labelling cause harm (by society)?

Yes
  • People may be viewed and react as mentally disturbed
  • Society attaches stigma to abnormality
  • Stigma can mark those with mental illness as 2nd class citizens
---> this judgement could perhaps make the mental disorder worse - labels can have devastating effects on a person's morale, self-esteem, and relationships with others

(p. 144 abnormal textbook)

What are the consequences of labelling?

Stigma may explain why 70% of people with diagnosable mental disorders do not seek treatment

What are the erroneous beliefs of mental illness?

- mental disorder is a sign of personal weakness (fundamentally different from physical injuries)
- psychiatric patients are dangerous

---> unfortunately the erroneous beliefs shape the way we view mental disorders
---> education about mental disorders dispels the stigma (at least this is what it tries to do)

What figures show the power of the mental health stigma?

  • 33% would not seek counseling for fear of being labeled “mentally ill”
  • 51% would hesitate to see a psychotherapist if a diagnosis were required
  • 67% would not tell their employer that they were seeking mental health treatment
  • 37% would be reluctant to seek treatment because of confidential concerns
  • 41% believe they be able to handle psychological problems on their own

---> American sample: perhaps in the US people are less inclined to seek mental health?

What is meant by prevalence and incidence?

  • Prevalence = Number of active cases in a population at a given point in time (e.g. point prevalence, 1-year prevalence, life-time prevalence)


  • Incidence = Number of new cases that occur over a given period of time (typically 1 year).


(see slide 4, p. 9 lecture notes for tables and figures of mental disorder occurrence)

The question on the page originate from the summary of the following study material:

  • A unique study and practice tool
  • Never study anything twice again
  • Get the grades you hope for
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Remember faster, study better. Scientifically proven.
Trustpilot Logo