Methodological fit in management field research EDMONDSON ADN MCMANUS

14 important questions on Methodological fit in management field research EDMONDSON ADN MCMANUS

What is the purpose of the paper of Edmondson and MacManus?

Seeks to provide guidance to align theory with method (fit)

How is a methodological fit in field research created?

Through an iterative learning process that requires a mindset in which feedback, rethinking, and revising are embraced as valued activities, and to discuss the implications of this for educating new fields researchers

Fit refers to consistency between elements, which are these elements?

  • Research questions
  • Prior work
  • Research design
  • Contribution to literature
  • Higher grades + faster learning
  • Never study anything twice
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Discover Study Smart

The state of theory is separated in three different archetypes of methodological fit in field research, what are these three states of theory?

  • Nascent categories
  • Intermediate categories
  • Mature categories

What is nascent theory?

Topics for which little or no previous theory exists

What is intermediate theory?

Intermediate theory research draws from prior work, often from separate bodies of literature to propose new constructs and/or provisional theoretical relationships. Mide provide new insight.

What are the data collection and analysis for mismatch mature theory and the problem that come with it?

Qualitative only --> Reinventing the wheel
Hybried --> Uneven status of evidence

What are the data collection and analysis mismatch for intermediate theory and the problem that come with it?

Quantitative only --> Uneven status of empirical measures
Qualitative only --> Lost opportunity

What are the data collection and analysis mismatch for nascent theory and the problem that come with it?

Qualitative only --> fishing exepditions
Hybrid --> quantitiave measures with uncertain relationship to pehnomena

What are the outcomes when methodological fit is low of Mature, Intermediate and Nascent theory?

  • Mature: Research fails to build
  • Intermediate: Results are less convincing
  • Nascent: Research falls too far outside guidelines for statistical inference to convince other of its mertis

Where to the authors Edmondson and Macmanus elaborate their field research on?

They elaborate extensively on field research as iterative, cyclic learning journey

What potential mistake does a student make if, a priori, he statses "I want to do a quantitative thesis" without an extensive literature review?

The student might do research on topics that already have been researched, or choose a topic where there is no sufficient data available (nascent topic)

How can you relate the iterative cycle learning journey of edmondson an MacManus to time management for a master thesis?

In order to structurally make your master thesis, you have to follow the right steps at the right time, in order to save time in later stages. When you submit your paper only to then realise the study has been done before in prior research, you have wasted all you time. Also, you can research what other did and did not do, in order to prevent falling into pitfalls other have fallen into.

What are the iterative steps in the cyclic learning of Edmondson and MacManus?

  • Identify area of interest
  • Read the literature
  • Develop research questions
  • Design a study
  • Collect data and anaylze data
  • Write up results
  • Submit

The question on the page originate from the summary of the following study material:

  • A unique study and practice tool
  • Never study anything twice again
  • Get the grades you hope for
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Remember faster, study better. Scientifically proven.
Trustpilot Logo