Processual and post-processual critique

10 important questions on Processual and post-processual critique

What where the views of Binford? (new archaeology)

  • Scientific methods (to date organic matter for example = link between archaeological questions, material and other disciplines)
  • Archaeology is about human behaviour; Human behaviour shows patterning across time and space. We can use those generalities to recognize them in the archaeological record
  • Away with history
  • Logical positivism (scientific knowledge is the only kind of factual knowledge)
  • Hypothetic-deductive reasoning = verifiable work (justified true believe)
  • Observation, falsification, and hypothesis testing

What were the views of Clarke? (new archaeology)

  • Testing is important, but no natural science
  • Closer to the artifacts, rather than human behaviour
  • Interested in statistics, in systematizing our understanding of how human societies developed over time

Processual archaeology characteristics

  • Identifying evolutionary stages in past societies
  • Stressing the systemic structure of past societies
  • The external environment was key in understanding material culture (Cultural Ecology)
  • Foregrounding scientific approaches to the material past
  • Towards the notion of process
  • Being explicit regarding one’s assumptions and concepts
  • Arguing for control of variability in an archaeological record
  • Higher grades + faster learning
  • Never study anything twice
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Discover Study Smart

Processual archaeology point 1: Identifying evolutionary stages in past societies

  • Internal dynamics
  • Understanding societal complexity
  • Identify the driving patterns in societies that can be seen as the cause of change that leads to a more complex society

Processual archaeology point 2: stressing the systemic structure of past societies

  • There is a predictable regularity to the study of human past
  • Economic, religious and social developments were all equal parts of that system

Processual archaeology point 3: the external environment was key in understanding material culture (Cultural Ecology)

  • Newly developed techniques (faunal, botanical analysis, 14c dating)
  • Research entire ecological surroundings (Cult-His only objects)
  • How do societies relate to their natural surrounding?

Processual archaeology point 4: foregrounding scientific approaches to the material past

  • Taking a distance from history
  • Looked at humans, as a species that was adapting to its surrounding, use of culture to do so

Processual archaeology point 5: towards the notion of process

  • Moving from ‘when’ to ‘why’
    • From descriptions of artefacts->  social, economic, ideological process
    • Preference for the development of process (craft specialization, production intensity)
    • An emphasis on longer-term trajectories

Processual archaeology point 6: being explicit regarding one's assumptions and concepts

  • Rather than assuming vague explanatory terms
  • Provide context to approach chosen
  • Further the verifiability (controleerbaarheid) and the testing of archaeological research (Cult-hist: relying on expert knowledge or intuition)

Processual archaeology point 7: arguing for control of variability in archaeological record

  • Focus on entire distribution of artifacts  (cult-his: iconic sites and artifacts)
  • Offsite research

The question on the page originate from the summary of the following study material:

  • A unique study and practice tool
  • Never study anything twice again
  • Get the grades you hope for
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Remember faster, study better. Scientifically proven.
Trustpilot Logo