Forests, Water and Climate

25 important questions on Forests, Water and Climate

Are forests hydrologically beneficial?

Forests have a very complex role and net effect depends on the scale you're looking at.

What did they find in a Wagon Wheel research in Colorado 1928:

A higher streamflow results from deforestation

Give the formula for a model for the Budyko curve to calculate E/P or water balance partitioning? What did they find?

Paste formula slide 9.

  • Land cover matters: grass vs. Forest (increased w with more vegetation)
  • Streamflow increases with deforestation, as evaporation increases. (min 21)
  • Higher grades + faster learning
  • Never study anything twice
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Discover Study Smart

Another model of Zhang: estimating annual ET from annual P, depending on land cover. What is their main finding?

  • ET increases in increasingly forested catchments

Give the formulas from Zhang et al. (2001) for ET in a catchment, both the general relation (simplified version of fitted model) and the fitted model.

Min 25!!! For example Qs
Play around with this formulas yourself!

Paste formulas.
f = fraction of forest cover
ETh = for short vegetation?

Partitioning of terrestrial evapotranspiration. What are main partitioners for global and forest scales?

T=transpiration
E = evaporation

Global:
Transpiration via stomata 80%
Bare soil E 11%
Interception E 7%
Snow sublimation 2%

Forest (Germany)
Interception E 44%
Transpiration via stomata 37%
Bare soil evaporation 19%

Interception capacity is higher in forest, especially in needle forests, that have high interception capacity in winter (copmared to bare fields).
Forests aerodynamiccaly stronger coupled than lower vegetation.  
Turbulence/rough surface from forests, that enables higher ET.
Annually, this apparantly becomes larger than T.

Lower streamflow, .. (min 30)

What is a negative effect of FLUXNET, that measures turbulence?

Eddy covariance flux towers (FLUXNET)
Measure turbulence

Quite a bit of uncertainty higher sthigher streamflow after deforestationream (min 31) .
Streamflow is a slow process, that can be measured properly by eddy covar(?)

Turbulence processes produce sampling uncertainty (one aspect).

Only global network for measuring ET.
          higher streamflow after deforestation

Forest ET paradox: two contradicting concluding papers. Why can the sign of ET be either +/- in these papers?

Different measurement techniques and a lot of uncertainty

Explain the Castricum lysimeter experiment: why lysimeters and why was this location chosen?

A lysimeter allows a more controlled catchment set-up that allows less bias in measuring surface runoff/streamflow(min 35).

North-Holland is main drinking water source for Amsterdam. Water managers wanted to know the land cover that gains most drinking water.

Explain main findings of Castricum lysimeter experiment?

Bare soil, deciduous, coniferous, short vegetation (duinstruweel), precipitation.

Coniferous: very water limited system, difference between blue and green line is the drainage from base of root zone. This is very little for the coniferous forest, where the coniferous forests grows/matures over time, the difference becomes smaller and water availability reduces further.

Bare soil has the largest difference. For the drinking company, bare soil allows higher water extraction.   


More GW recharge and more salt water pushback in the Dutch Dunes on bare soils.

Check min 55: What is the sponge theory and what is the current status of debate?

The idea that forests have a positive hydrologically beneficial effects: buffering streamflow and make it available in the dry season.
Already criticism since 100 years. Currently, there is still a large debate. People might like to see that forests only have positive effects.

Min 57-61: What is the effect of forests on peak flow?

Forests would have a reduced effect on peak flows (result of sponge theory). Scientific evidence however is limited. Somehow finding evidence or proper methods to measure cannot be found.

Effect on permeability, rooting depth, etc. Might not be well modeled.
Observation based studies show there is no influence -->??

What are the effects of forests in boreal areas?

In boreal forests, deforestation generally causes cooling due to increased albedo effect.

Min 71

Min 74-77: energy explanation!

Temp is much closer to atmosphere temp. Grass warms up more,

Grassland:
Sensible heat is compressed

Forests:
Sensible heat flux (warming of atmosphere)
ET is compressed
Forests in NL have a warming effect on atmosphere (different than walking in the forest, which is cooling).

Min 80: Relation on forests and clouds: very confusing signals. Give

Amazon: Local deforestation causes local increase in cloud cover. Local heating is enhanced in a moist environment, local rising air that is already humid, at clouds there's highest heating, not highest ET.

Australia: clear distinction farmland (no clouds) and scrubland (with clouds).  Thus opposite of occurence in Amazon.

Review paper Lawrence & Vandecar (2015): processes  min 81

If you deforest, you remove vegetatino with deep roots. Thus maybe higher sensible heat flux, leads to local updrift of air. Local circulation
...

Locally: deforestation leads to increase of clouds, but you need the ... From local regions.

As turbulence, clouds are very erratic. Continuous sampling averaging over many days are necessary to measure clouds. How is this done?

Geostationary satellites:
15 min, 1 km resolution

When researching clouds, you should exclude topography (so no mountainous areas).

What happens in the EU forests on the front of cloud cover, based on the satellite data?

In EU, forests increase the cloud cover and probably rainfall. Probably true for both Veluwe and French forest. Increased rainfall (and thunderstorms) > increased ET > possibly increased rainfall later on. This is not visible at the surroundings.

Tropics: ET or sensible heating?  -_> Min 88/89!!

Same process in tropics: higher sensible heating in the (non?)-forest areas. Forests reduce ET, increase sensible heating, this sensible heating causes the cloud formation.

Link with energy cycle that explains cloud formation.  

Turbulence and sensible heating of land surface. Some wind direction effects.

What is the forest-breeze in the tropics?

Min 89/90

What was the impact of cyclone Klaus?

Reduced the cloud formation after trees were destroyed by the cyclone.

How do mega-cities impact cloud cover?

Cities generate a lot of runoff and have low ET.  However, forest effect is similar to city effect on cloud cover. Higher sensible heating in cities as well, on average low ET in cities, high ET in forests. On very dry days: ET is reduced/low and sensible heating is high, this generates clouds. Forests behave similar to large cities (London, Paris-sized) when it comes to cloud cover.

Larger scale (Spracklen 2012 & Aragao 2012) : more ET on average means that this ET should go somewhere. (min 92)

1 mm is a lot of water!
P = precip

Spracklen:
Air passing over forest day before: P was higher. Very difficult to quantify this.

Aragao:
Forest: rainfall recycling
Deforest: remove ET, increase runoff
Further deforest: ET gets very low, reduced rainfall, runoff more direct.
Water cycle and downwind precip is changed while deforesting.

Feedbacks might play at larger scale than previously though.

Explain main findings of forests on water on smaller and larger scales?

Smaller scale: Average streamflow at smaller scale
Larger scale: remote rainfall, .. rainfall,  (min 100:50). Moisture recycling.

Lot of debate and uncertainty still going on.

What is the forest effect on a small scale?

Local scale: Increased ET due to forests, that will eventually P.
On larger scale: adding this up, forests may cause increased P due to increased ET, hence the runoff may be compensated by this increased P.

The question on the page originate from the summary of the following study material:

  • A unique study and practice tool
  • Never study anything twice again
  • Get the grades you hope for
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Remember faster, study better. Scientifically proven.
Trustpilot Logo