Interest of shareholders as a class

23 important questions on Interest of shareholders as a class

Why is corporate law restricted in making strict regulations for business decisions?

1. Judges are poorly equipped to make business decisions.
- Hindsight bias: can make even the most reasonable managerial decision seem reckless.

2. Business directors will be less willing to choose risky projects with high returns. They will go for safer options with low returns

To solve the agency problem, would it be a solution to shift all the decision making to the shareholders?

No. Delegated management works. It's too costly for shareholders and it will deprive them from all the benefits of letting a small number of experts make the decisions.

Explain how the reward strategy may substitute for shareholder decision rights

Good pay packages ca align the interest of the managers with those of the shareholders. So rewarding the managers will result in the right decisions being made in favor of the principal
  • Higher grades + faster learning
  • Never study anything twice
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Discover Study Smart

Why would appointment and decision rights be relatively strong in countries where controlling shareholders are common?

There is no need for agreement with minority shareholders, since the controlling shareholders have direct control over management. So appointment and decision rights are strong for controlling shareholders.

True or false: "appointment and decision rights always enable shareholders to exert influence directly over the management"

False. In countries where smaller investors that are passive and uninformved, appointment and decision rights are less effective. They simply do not care how the company runs, but rather how much return they make

What are shareholder centric laws?

Shareholders have a lot of removal power


Example: UK, France, Japan, Brazil - provide shareholders with non-waivable removal powers and nomination powers

What is proxy access?

Providing shareholders with the ability to include their own candidates

Why is the US not centric?

1. Proxy access
2. Short terms of one year

Give an example of shareholder decision rights

1. Voting
2. Approval of mergers
3. Charter amendments
4. Appointing people to the board

What is the difference between two-tier boards and one-tier boards?

Two-tier (Germany)
1. Supervisory board is separate from the directors (oversight management)
2. Supervisory board is elected by shareholders
3. Supervisory board appoints directors

One tier (US)
Supervision and management are on one board

What is the most common approach in the selection process of directors?

Board proposes a slate of nominees that is rarely opposes at the annual shareholder meeting

Why is it preferable to let the board perform the search and selection function of nominees?

Due to high information and coordination costs

What is the plurality voting rule under Delaware law?

When the number of candidates equals the number of directors to be elected, any number of votes suffices to elect a candidate to a board seat.

What are four voting mechanisms to make voting less costly?

1. Voting online
2. Proxy solicitation by corporate partisans (voting for each other)
3. Proxy voting through custodial institutions
4. Electroninc meeting

What is the constraint strategy?

All jurisdictions impose  a very broad duty on directors to take reasonable care of their offices

What is the business judgement rule under constraint strategy?

Germany: if management board members can prove that at the time of the decision they had good reason to assume that they were acting on the basis of adequate information for the benefit of the company, no judge can rule that they have violated a law

Why do a corporations non-contractual stakeholders have a greater need for legal protection than contractual counterparties?

If corporations are engaging in socially harmful behaviour (environment, human rights) then third parties cannot protect themselves through contract, hence they need extra legal protection

What are examples of deviations of the one-share-one-vote norm?

- Dual class equity structure
- Circulars shareholding
- Pyramid ownership structures

What is the effetive governance strategy?

Majority of the minority shareholders approve transactions between controlling shareholders and their corporations

What does the German law in "quasi-parity codetermination" mean?

Employee directors comprise half of the supervisory board in German companies

What did the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 mandate?

Wholly independent audit commitees

What did the Dodd Frank act mandate?

Independent compensation commitees

What are the two forms of incentive strategy?

1. Equal treatment
2. Trusteeship
(Some jurisdictions voting rights for minority shareholders)

The question on the page originate from the summary of the following study material:

  • A unique study and practice tool
  • Never study anything twice again
  • Get the grades you hope for
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Remember faster, study better. Scientifically proven.
Trustpilot Logo