Beliefs and Attitudes

24 important questions on Beliefs and Attitudes

Who was Theodor Adorno and what did he propose?

A German Jew who was greatly influenced by the rise and dominance of the Nazis and Fascism

Proposed:
The authoritarian personality  
Adorno felt that fear and aggression predicted conservatism

What did Adorno argue about the upbringing of authoritarians? What did he link this upbringing to?

They were from a strict upbringing - this caused their authoritarian beliefs

---> Adorno also linked this upbringing to racist and facist views

(p. 557 differential textbook)

Adorno's theory took a psychodynamic view. What does this mean?

Their theory emphasised the interaction of various conscious and unconscious mental or emotional processes and particularly their effects on personality, behaviour and attitudes

---> Adorno used such a view to present authoritarianism as the identification of submissive behaviour towards authority, with the authoritarian person directing their aggression towards other social groups, often racial minorities, in an attempt to resolve feelings of personal weakness

(p. 557 differential textbook)
  • Higher grades + faster learning
  • Never study anything twice
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Discover Study Smart

What did Theodor Adorno create?

The authoritarian F (or the Fascism scale) (1950)

---> Draws on a lot of fascist ideology, particularly Nazi
---> Seems very old-fashioned now, rooted in post-war america

Examples of statements
  • 'What the youth needs most is strict discipline, rugged determination, and the will to work and fight for family and country
  • People can be divided into two distinct categories: the weak and the strong
  • Obedience and respect for authority are the most important virtues children should learn

Adorno’s sense = irrational, antiscientific, anti-intellectual, shoddy thinking underlies authoritarianism

What deficiencies did Altemeyer point out about the Fascism scale?

  • Old-fashioned, insufficiently captures modern political attitudes
  • Authoritarianism is really right-wing authoritarianism - what about left-wing authoritarianism? = this area seems neglected

What criticisms did Gul and Ray (1989) say about Adorno's F scale?

They argues that authoritarianism as measured by the F scale:
- reflects common myths and superstitions
- has an old-fashioned orientation/outlook rather than any popular viewpoint 

---> they argued that Adorno's F scale was outdated rather than incorrect

(p. 557 differential textbook)

What was Altmeyer's right wing authoritarianism scale and when was it published?

1997
---> Some similarity to Adorno’s questionnaire, but less obviously out of date
---> ideas more simple that Adorno's

Examples of statements
  • Women should have to promise to obey their husbands when they get married
  • It is always better to trust the judgement of the proper authorities in government and religion than to listen to the noisy rabble-rousers in our society who are trying to create doubt in people's minds
  • Our country needs free thinkers who will have the courage to defy traditional ways, even if this upsets many people

What are the main aspects of Altemeyer's (1996) model of right with authoritarianism?

  • Trust authorities too much
  • Accept abuses of power by government
  • Prejudiced on racial, ethnic, nationalist and sexual grounds
  • Cause and inflame intergroup conflict
  • Accept insufficient evidence to support their beliefs
  • Punitive attitudes

What are the differences between Adorno's and Altemeyer's authoritarianism ideas regarding the type of view?

Altemeyer changes the emphasis from Adorno's psychodynamic approach and highlights more cognitive processes (thoughts and thinking strategies) regarding how right-wing authoritarians perceive and deal with information

(p. 558 differential textbook)

What did Meloen at al, 1996 investigate?

They compared 4 types of authoritarian questionnaires

Results

1) The various scales of right-wing authoritarianism:

a) Strongly predict (+ correlation) right-wing social/political stances, e.g. apartheid, anti-semitism, isolating AIDS victims
b) moderately predict sympathy for right-wing political parties (strongest prediction for the Racist political party)

2) Pattern of correlations does not differ much across the different scales

What did Zakrisson, 2005 investigate?

They modernised/ revisited Altmeyer's Right-wing authoritarianism scale
= 15 item version
= Sample: 17-50 year olds

Results
- reasonable internal consistency
- predicts modern racism and modern sexism in Sweden

What did Wilson (1973) argue were conservative attitudes?

- religious fundamentalism
- pro-establishment politics
- advocacy of strict rules and punishment
- militarism
- intolerance of minority groups
- conventional tastes in art/ clothing
- restrictions on sexual activity
- opposition to scientific progression
- tendency to be superstitious

(p. 558 differential textbook)

How did Wilson measure conservatism?

The Wilson-Patterson Attitude Inventory (WPAI)

---> 50 questions
e.g. whether they are in favour of such things like the death penalty or abortion

(p. 559 differential textbook)

What 4 primary theoretical viewpoints of conservatism did Wilson (1973) suggest?

1. Resistance to change i.e. a preference for traditional existing institutions (e.g. churches) whereas social change is resisted
2. Tendency to play safe i.e. moderate, cautious, and avoid risks
3. Reflecting the distinction between generations
4. Internalisation of parental values

(p. 561 differential textbook)

What did Carney et al (2008) find in terms of the personality traits of liberals and conservatives?

Liberals:
- open to experience
- extravert

Conservatives:
- conscientious
- neurotic
- not open to experience

What did Jost et al (2003) find in terms of traits associated with left/right wing people?

Wide-ranging, influential meta-analysis  of 88 studies involving > 22,000 subjects

Conservatism is positively correlated with:
- dogmatism
- intolerance of ambiguity (suggests they have a tendency of premature closure)
- need for order
- need for cognitive closure

Conservatism is negatively correlated with:
- general sensation seeking
- valuing imaginativeness
- openness to experience
- self-esteem (on average, much smaller effect)

Taking the presented studies into consideration, what are the most salient and robust characteristics of conservatism and liberalism?

Conservativism correlates with more active systems focused upon self-protection and disease-avoidance (i.e. aversion) (leaning towards behavioural inhibition)

Liberalism correlates with more active system focused upon social and other reward (i.e. appetitive)

What is the summary regarding traits for liberal and conservatives?

Liberals/left of centre

Overview:
‘Excited’
Appetitive/Approach oriented
More active Gray’s BAS

For example:
Less anxious, neurotic
Less prone to disgust
More Sensation seeking
Excited by Novelty
Open to Experience/Tolerant of Ambiguity
Less need for cognitive closure
Lower Conscientiousness

Conservative/Right of centre


Overview:
‘Threatened’, ‘Defensive’
Aversive oriented
More active Gray’s BIS

For example:
More Anxious, Neurotic
More Prone to disgust
Less sensation seeking
Suspicious of novelty
Closed to experience/Intolerant of ambiguity
Higher Need for cognitive closure
Higher Conscientiousness

What is the interpretation of Amodio et al's (2007) results?

Liberals show stronger brain reactivity to cues signalling a need to change a prepotent response pattern

This resulted in better performance on the task, though brain activity predicts political preference better than task response accuracy

Who demonstrated that political orientations are correlated with brain structure?

Kanai et al (2011)

Study 1: 90 young adults, 55 female, mean 23 years old
Study 2: 28 young adults new sample, 16 female, mean 21 years old

Single-item measure: participants self-report their political orientation as  ‘Very Liberal’ (1), ‘Liberal’ (2), ‘Middle of the road’ (3), ‘Conservative (4), or ‘Very Conservative’ (5)

Results
  • The larger your anterior cingulate, the more ‘Liberal’ you are
  • The larger your right amygdala, the more ‘Conservative’ you are 

Regarding Kanai et al's (2011) study, what is a limitation regarding the sample?

  • Not a single participant classed themselves as ‘very conservative’ so the scale ranged from 1-4
  • UCL student population is disproportionately middle-class and upper class

How does right-wing attitudes link to Eysenck's theory of personality?

Within Eysenck's theory, right-wing attitudes are linked to psychoticism

---> Eysenck (1985) defined the nature of psychoticism as compromising cruel, insensitive, unfriendly, and anti-social traits

(p. 564 differential textbook)

How does the 5 factor theory of personality and conservatism/right wing attitudes?

Remember, the five factor model of personality consists of 5 personality types: openness, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, neuroticism

  • Right-wing authoritarianism is negatively related to openness to experience
  • Right-wing authoritarianism is positively correlated to conscientiousness (Heaven & Bucci, 2001)
  • Social dominance is negatively related to openness to experience and agreeableness

---> main findings across studies = the relationship between right-wing attitudes and the two-personality dimensions of agreeableness and conscientiousness

---> using 3 factor model = psychoticism is related to right-wing attitudes

(p. 565-566 differential textbook)

What are criticisms of right-wing attitudes theories?

  • This area of study is vulnerable to changes over time
  • Different cultures will have different ideas of what is a right-wing attitude

(p. 567 differential textbook)

The question on the page originate from the summary of the following study material:

  • A unique study and practice tool
  • Never study anything twice again
  • Get the grades you hope for
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Remember faster, study better. Scientifically proven.
Trustpilot Logo