Ppt; Dutch citizenship education policy & perspectives on passivity

15 important questions on Ppt; Dutch citizenship education policy & perspectives on passivity

Name three fairly seperate worlds?

* Science
* Policy
* Practice

Policy in the NL's from an empirical perspective.
Citizenship education in NL.

1) Debated since WWII
2) A few core objectives (kerndoelen) relate to citizenship education
3) There's some misguided legislation for vocational education ('vital citizenship')
4) Typically not a subject, little teacher training
5) New legislation just in place

Policy in the NLs from a theoretical perspective.
How does NL compare to Europe with regard to policy and practice?

Tekst van Veugelers.

Strong practice / Strong policy: Germany, Finland
Strong practice / Policy requiring attention: Spain
Practice requiring attention / Strong policy: Estonia, Romania, Slovenia, UK
Practice requiring attention / Policy requiring attention: Czech Republic, Greece, France, NL, Poland.
  • Higher grades + faster learning
  • Never study anything twice
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Discover Study Smart

Policy makeing: There are two problematic assumptions, which?

1) Citizenship as an 'essentially contested notion'
> suggests no consesnsus is possible

2) Freedom of education as an absolute standard
> suggests any national policy is undesirable

Citizenship education policy: Theory
What constitutes a community?

Citizenship is always about being a member of a (social or political) community
But what constitutes a community?
• Every community has ‘walls’ / barriers for entry and exit
- Jehova’s Witnesses
- Your regular pub
• Every community has to deal with the question of power

Citizenship Education Policy: Theory
Whose needs should a community serve?
Which ideals should be pursued?

That depends on…
- Our beliefs (or findings) about the social nature of man
- Our beliefs (or ideals) about the social ordering of relations

Types of Freedom? (Isaiah Berlin)

Negative freedom: freedom from... Interference or free from something.

Positive freedom: freedom to... freedom as self-mastery or 'free to do something'

Why would we need national legislation?

A democratic structure is not sufficient for a truly democratic society.
For a truly democratic society a democratic culture is necessary as well.
Therefore, no citizenship education is naïve and comes with great costs.

Citizenship Education and Freedom
How do three options impact the positive and negative freedom of young citizens?

1) Teaching what to think; teaching values; teaching behavior

2) Teaching critical thinking; teaching how democracy works; teaching citizenship competences

3) Teaching subjects; teaching how to learn; teching about societal issues

New citizenship education law...

1. Puts liberal democratic values and knowledge at its core
2. Demands of schools to formulate a vision and learning objectives
3. Demands of school personnel to act within liberal democratic values
4. Requires schools to do quality assurance
5. Allows schools a fair amount of autonomy

Citizenship: values, behaviour and competence
Teacher's dilemma...

What if a student shouts out:
‘All Jews should be gassed’
or asks:
‘I’m not pro-sexual diversity, why are we celebrating this at school?’ during class?

Standby citizens: diverse faces of political passivity

Authors: Erik Amnå & Joakim Ekman
A study into the political dimension of citizenship

Main question: can we discern different types of political passitivity?

Political passivity - A problem?


Amnå and Ekman mention a number of concerns that relate to political passivity:
• Low party membership
• Low turnout levels during election
• Eroding public confidence in public institutions
• Lack of trust in politicians and political parties

Note: the authors do not give indications of the amount of change over timeNote: not all of these trends are necessarily negative (as the authors mention)

Political passivity: a problem?

It also depends on one’s view of democracy:
• Minimalist model of democracy (passivity is good, esp. for the non qualified)
[vanuit een elitair standpunt zijn er kennelijk mensen die niet gekwalificeerd zijn om mee te doen...]
• Participatory model of democracy (passivity is bad, it hampers good decision making and active citizenship is a virtue in and of itself)
• Representative model (sense of civic duty should be combined with a willingness to be governed)

Is mere political activity sufficient to sustain democracy?

DISCUSSION: FROM VIOLENT ACTIVISM TO
DISILLUSIONMENT WHAT EXPLAINS THE
DIFFERENT TRAJECTORIES?


Hypothesis: perhaps the relevant ingredients are:
- A feeling that something is (deeply) unjust or wrong
- Feeling powerless to bring about change with the current system
- Social support of like minded peers (or the absence of support)

What implications are there for education?
Do you see reflections of societal trends?

The question on the page originate from the summary of the following study material:

  • A unique study and practice tool
  • Never study anything twice again
  • Get the grades you hope for
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Remember faster, study better. Scientifically proven.
Trustpilot Logo