Decision making framework & systems design

23 important questions on Decision making framework & systems design

What goal of food companies regarding Food safety?

Optimise the level of food safety
  • Moneterized risk of contamination
  • Expected benefit of high quality image

What are task of the government regarding food safety?

  • Task for public health
  • By organising health care system
  • By regulating food safety

What are 5 different decision making decision options for the government ?

  • Expert: trusted expert
  • Consensus:  common position in group of stakeholders
  • Political: representatives of political parties
  • Benchmarking: decision base on outside models, such international regulation
  • Empirical: base on fact-finding an analyses using parameters
  • Higher grades + faster learning
  • Never study anything twice
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Discover Study Smart

What are three methods for calculation of risk(monetary benefits)

  1. Cost minimisation analysis
  2. cost-effectiveness analysis
  3. Cost-utility analysis

What general characteristics of cost minimisation analysis?

  • Known outcome (animal decease/ verdwijnen)
  • Several programs with the same outcome
  • Only monetary cost
    • net costs:
      • Program costs( K)
      • Monetary benefits (^W)
      • K-^W

When and how to use cost minimisation analysis ?

When:
  • Reach a mandatory maximum level of contamination
  • eradicate a zoonosis (other animal desiease)


How:
  • Identify approaches
  • Make sure that the approaches lead to desired result
  • Calculate cost & 'side' benefits of approaches -> net costs
  • Compare net costs and select

What are limitation of cost-minimisation analysis?

  • All programmes need to reach same level (threshold)
  • What if that threshold is not clear
  • Cost or budget driven

What are the general characteristics of cost effectiveness analysis?

  • Single non-monetary effect
    • Usually sprees in chang in physical using such as:
    • #days with illness
  • All other effects expressed in monetary units
  • Cost-effective ratios
    • (K-^W)/^SE
    • ^SE= effect of intervention

When and how to use cost effectiveness analysis ?

When:
  • one singel outcome effect
  • Programmes have different levels of effectiveness


How:
  • Define pragrammes
  • Evaluate effect of each individual program
  • Define net cost
  • Evaluate cost-effectiveness
  • Rank various programmes

How do rank alternatives?

Plot it in a graph, set minimal/max levels

What are limitations of cost effectiveness analysis ?

  • Only one outcome variable possible (only one type of contamination)
  • What if factious programmes affect different contaminations

What are the general characteristics of cost utility analysis?

  • Weighing various outcome
  • Single combined measurement of non-monetary effects into one sling metric unit
  • All other effects expressed in monetary units
  • Cost - utility ratio
  • Can use same rank metrics

What are limitations of cost utility analysis?

  • You need to have a utility measurement
  • What is the value of one "utility"
  • Ranking is still difficult


  • Social cost-benefit analysis (goal)

What is social cost benefit analysis ?

  • All effects, both monetary and intangible, direct and indirect, are measure and expressed in cometary terms
  • Underlying theoretical assumption
    • Within a society, those who gain could compensate hose who lose by reallocation resources
  • Evaluation: net value

What are general characteristics  of social benefit analysis ?

  • Moste complete quantitative approach
  • Gold standard; cost-benefit using societal perspective
  • Advantage: allows to compare all governmental programs
  • Disadvantage: monetarization of all effects requires immense amounts of assumptions

What are limitations of individual WTP?

  • Most commonly used methods do not adequately capture individual disutility from morbidity
  • Willingness to pay reflects ability to pay, therefore, current income distribution
  • There is significant disagreement combination of utility measure and their combination with other monetary valuation measures.

What is systems approach?

Mathematical modelling is set of equations to describe or simulate parts of the real world

What are 2 systems approach loss?

  • Positive approach -Looking back - time consuming/expensive
  • Normative approach - forward - Model vs reality

How to study the economics of food safety?

Changes in output of a food system, given infrastructure, input and food safety issues

What are the 6 steps in systems analysis ?

  1. Define systems and objectives , stakeholders/process in play
  2. Gather data
  3. Construct the model
  4. Validate the model
  5. Carry out sensitivity analysis
  6. Write down results

How to define a system ? 3 tegenstellingen


  • Static vs dynamic
  • Deterministic vs stochastic
  • Optimisation vs simulation

Why validation in modelling ?

  • Internal
    • during model building
    • logic of the model
    • Assumptions vs knowledge
  • External
    • Model vs real system

What sensitivity analysis in modelling>

  • Powerful option of models
  • Effect of assumptions on outcome
    • input for further (empirical research)
    • Single effects
    • Combined effect, interaction
    • Controlled vs uncontrolled

The question on the page originate from the summary of the following study material:

  • A unique study and practice tool
  • Never study anything twice again
  • Get the grades you hope for
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Remember faster, study better. Scientifically proven.
Trustpilot Logo