Introduction institutions and principles

22 important questions on Introduction institutions and principles

How are int. Agreements implemented into domestic law

.Implementation of international agreements in domestic law:
• Indirectly, through the adoption of domestic law (or EU law), and/or
• Directly, if domestic constitutional law enables this (“monistic system”). In
this case, a MEA automatically becomes part of domestic law after
ratification by Parliament and entry into force. Its norms can be invoked
before domestic courts against the government in case these norms are
sufficiently clear and applicable in concrete cases.

What sort of governmental institutions do we have?

.International organisations
• Governmental organisations
• General or specialised
• Global or regional

What kind of non-governmental instiutions do we have?

.Non-governmental organisations (NGOs)
• Private organisations. Examples: Greenpeace, WWF
• Hybrid organisations (public/private): International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN)
  • Higher grades + faster learning
  • Never study anything twice
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Discover Study Smart

What is soft law sources?

.Soft law (declarations, non-binding resolutions and other decisions by
Conference of the Parties, guidelines, handbooks, etc

Is soft law adopted by states?

Yes but not signed.

What are exemples of soft law?

.Rio Declaration on Environment and Development 1992; Copenhagen
Accord on Climate Change 2009

What use does the soft law have?

However: 1) sometimes used to interpret legally binding obligations, 2) indicates
development of new rules: “soft law can become harder over time

What are private law sources?

.Private law sources
• Partnerships NGOs/businesses, “self-regulation”
• Rely on domestic private law, often have their own dispute resolution mechanism
Private entities kind of take of the role of the state, they create rules, enforce rules etc.  What if this private entity violates another right like human rights by trying to protect the environment? This is a current discussion and states and NGO’s can step in and keep them in check. Ultimately for example if human rights are violated the states have the responsibility!

What was so important about the earth summit? UN Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED, Rio de Janeiro 1992), “Earth Summit”

.Pivotal moment in development of international environmental law
• Largest conference on the environment ever, with almost all states present
• Adoption of many important international instruments:

What instruments were adopted at the earth summit?

.Rio Declaration on Environment and Development (soft law)
• Authoritative Statement on Forest Principles (soft law)
• Agenda 21 (soft law)
• UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) (hard law)
• Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) (hard law)
• UN Desertification Convention (officially signed 1994) (hard law)
• Acknowledgment of sustainable development as basis for environmental law and policy
• Developing countries start to raise their voice and assume a decisive role

What is the legal status of the principle of sustainable development?

.Briefly mentioned in some case law by international courts and
tribunals, not accepted as customary law

Where can we find Principle of intragenerational equity. And what is it?

You have to make sure that everyone has the same level of protection of the environment.Pay attention to special position developing countries and weak ethnic, religious, gender and social groups in societ

.Rio Declaration (principles 6, 7)
• See also (already) Stockholm Declaration: principles 9, 10, 11, 12

IN WHICH case was this principle (no harm) acknowledged and what is the case about?

.First acknowledged as customary international law in the Trail Smelter case (1938)
• Arbitration case between USA and Canada on metal smelters in Canada that polluted
agricultural areas across the border in the USA
• ‘Under the principles of international law (...) no State has the right to use or permit the
use of its territory in such a manner as to cause injury by fumes in or to the territory of
another or the properties of persons therein.’
• This case is considered by many as the birthplace of international environmental law

What is the consulation and co-operation principle

.Consultation and co-operation principle
• To protect the environment, states should work together
• Examples: Espoo Convention on environmental impact assessment in transboundary
context, Rio Declaration (principles 5, 7, 9, 12, 14 etc.)

What is the EIA principle and what are exemples?

.Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) principle
• Carry out an EIA for proposed activities that are likely to have a significant adverse
impact on the environment
• Examples: Rio Declaration (principle 17), Pulp Mills case (see session 3)
• Plays important role in EU environmental law

What is the pollutor pays principle?

.Polluter Pays Principle
• Polluter has to bare the costs of environmental pollution, use financial/economic
instruments to make sure that the costs of environmental harm are integrated in the
price of activities/products (example: carbon tax)
• Example: Rio Declaration (principle 16)
• Not widely applied, has been acknowledged in EU environmental law and plays some
role there

Why is there more soft law than hard law?

States don’t want to commit to hard law, therefore soft law is a better solution for states. Countries will not get on board of a certain legal text because they think the obligations are to far reaching for them. Then it is easier to adopt the same document however as soft law because it won’t be legally binding

.What is the UNCED? What legal instruments were concluded at this conference? What is their respective legal status

The UNCED is the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development also known as the ‘Earth Summit’ Since UNCED the relationship between environmental protection and economic development has been more fully recognized by the international community

Why are treaties and mea's so important?

Why is this relevant for national law?  These conventions are agreements between states, its not between states and individual peoples or NGOs.  There is still relevance on the national level. Gedownload door Esmee De Koning (esmay100@gmail.com) lOMoARcPSD|5097417  If states agree to something then they will have to develop their own policies to try and prevent harm to the environment (which they made an agreement on)

What are regional and special organizations?

General organisations are organisations that deal with everything  Specialized organisations are organisations that only deal with a certain topic

What relationship does the SDG have with the UNCED rio declaration?

.UN Sustainable Development Goals (2015) (SDGs  build upon the Rio Declaration)

What has been the center of environmental law since UNCED?

The relationship between development and the environment has been centre stage in the international arena since UNCED

The question on the page originate from the summary of the following study material:

  • A unique study and practice tool
  • Never study anything twice again
  • Get the grades you hope for
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Remember faster, study better. Scientifically proven.
Trustpilot Logo