Meat authenticity and traceability

9 important questions on Meat authenticity and traceability

What is CWA 17369:2019 ?

Authenticity & fraud in feed & food chain - concepts, terms & definitions

  • Summerizes: what it is about / how it was structured / what it contains
  • Need to understand how product = influenced to determine what makes it authentic & how to use this information to protect product

How does meat authenticity & traceability differ?

  • Traceability = to identify the origin of a product trough all stages, mainly for safety & monitoring issues
  • Authenticity = to assure general quality attributes (independent of spatial & temporal contexts)

What can we do to combat meat fraud?

Regulations: to protect consumers (only way to prosecute)
  • Authorities define what constitutes "meat" for consumers
  • To ensure proper labeling & prevention of adulteration or other forms of fraud

However,
  • Enforcement of regulations does not always happen
  • Inconsistencies in regulations create loopholes = opportunities for fraud
  • Regulations not harmonised globally
  • Higher grades + faster learning
  • Never study anything twice
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Discover Study Smart

What are the driver(s) for meat fraud?

Price
  • Purchase cost-effective meat (low-income consumers)

Accessibility
  • Rural areas consumers have limited access & less variety to choose from
    • Purchase from unregulated/informal markets
    • Cheaper/processed products
    • Lower quality meat cuts
    • Consumers less concerned about product composition, more in cost saving (increases fraud)

Religion/belief
  • Concerned about product composition
    • Religious dietary laws have restrictions on consumption of certain animal proteins
      • Pork: Muslim/Halal, Jewish/Kashrut; Beef: Hindu
    • Magical/medicinal beliefs promote specific animal consumption
Origin / nature of meat
  • Purchase meat that fits with lifestyle
    • "healthier" options; sustainability choices

Why are consumer in rural areas more vulnerable to meat fraud?

  • No/limited control of food being sold
  • Easy to commit fraud
  • Sell products with special attributes
  • Sell processed products
  • Consumers
    • limited access & less choice
    • Dont question product composition
    • More concerned about price

What are the 2 general meat fraud issues?

  1. Mixing of meat types/sources = species substitution
    • Replace with cheaper undeclared meat types
    • Usually in unregulated/less regulated markets
    • Ethical issues - beef & pork
    • health issues - plant used & people with allergies
  2. Mislabeling
    • Origin-based claims (PDO, PGI, TSG)
    • Production system claims
    • Premium prices products

Name 3 examples of meat fraud

  • Re-grinding old meat with fresh --> improve colour
  • Washing expired meat with chlorine --> remove rotting smell
  • Adding water (water = cheap, increases weight & sold by price)
  • MSM sold fraudulently as minced meat
  • Disguise origins of constituents in processed meat products

Difference between targeted and non-targeted

Targeted
  • single or dual targets (chemical compounds) that are primary marker(s) for direct authentication through legal limits
  • single or dual targets (chemical elements, isotope ratios, metabolites, etc) that are secondary marker(s) or profiling using secondary markers for indirect authentication through threshold value(s) or database comparison

Non-targeted
  • fingerprinting using unspecified targets or data points for indirect authentication through a database or reference comparison

How would you authenticate iberico de bellota?

  • DNA/PCR-based methods
  • Stable isotopes / elements
  • Stable isotopes / elements or PTR-MS
  • DNA / PCR-based methods
  • Lipids or metabolites or volatiles

The question on the page originate from the summary of the following study material:

  • A unique study and practice tool
  • Never study anything twice again
  • Get the grades you hope for
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Remember faster, study better. Scientifically proven.
Trustpilot Logo