Taylor, Nigel. 1998. . The systems and rational process views of planning. In Taylor, Nigel. Urban Planning Theory since 1945, pp. 59-74

6 important questions on Taylor, Nigel. 1998. . The systems and rational process views of planning. In Taylor, Nigel. Urban Planning Theory since 1945, pp. 59-74

What are the two theories that emerged in 1960 regarding town planning, and how are they related to Anthony Giddens?

The two theories are the System view (theory of an object), which focuses on interconnected parts, and the Rational process view (process of planning), which emphasizes rational decision-making. Both have connections with Anthony Giddens.

What are the basic concepts of the System view of planning, and what are the six differences between this view and the traditional design-based view?

Basic concepts include systems composed of interconnected parts. Six differences:
    1. Planners used a survey-analysis-plan method to understand cities.
    2. Planning shifted from art (design and aesthetics) to science.
    3. Transition from end-state master plans to flexible plans.
    4. Planning became an ongoing process, not a one-time blueprint.
    5. Consideration of cities as systems of interconnected activities.
    6. A gap between theory and practice due to abstract and technical nature.

What is the Rational process view of planning, and what are the sources and factors that contributed to its development?

The Rational process view emphasizes procedural planning and decision-making. Sources include decision theory and government interest in management styles. Factors include renewed faith in applying "science" to policymaking.
  • Higher grades + faster learning
  • Never study anything twice
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Discover Study Smart

What are the three conditions for rational planning according to the text?

Three conditions for rational planning are:
    • Reasons for decisions should be carefully thought through.
    • Reasons for decisions should be explicit.
    • Each stage of the process should be carefully and explicitly thought through if the whole process is rational.

How is the Rational process model described in terms of being a normative model of planning and a model of instrumental (means-ends) reasoning?

The Rational process model is described as a normative model of planning, ideally guiding planning as a form of social action. It's also seen as a model of instrumental (means-ends) reasoning, focusing on the method or means of planning.

What is the debate mentioned in the text regarding "disjointed incremental" versus "rational comprehensive" planning, and what is Lindblom's perspective on this debate?

The debate centers on whether the Rational process view implies a 'comprehensive' approach to planning or a 'disjointed incremental' approach. Lindblom argued that 'real-world' planning is necessarily 'disjointed' and 'incremental,' not 'rational' and 'comprehensive.' He believed that the incremental approach was the only feasible one due to limited time and resources.

The question on the page originate from the summary of the following study material:

  • A unique study and practice tool
  • Never study anything twice again
  • Get the grades you hope for
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Remember faster, study better. Scientifically proven.
Trustpilot Logo