Doing policy analysis

8 important questions on Doing policy analysis

Analysis, advice and avocacy

-Analysis: gathers relevant data and transforms it into information to support decision making.
-Advice: Bridges the gap between analysis and decision, supporting decision makers to select and implement their preferred policy options.
-Advocacy: trying to persuade politicians, and the public, of the benefits of the recommended options.

Models about science and policy making

Technocratic
Decisionist
Inverted decisionist
Co-production

Two types of politics

Tornado politics: can resolve commitment to a specific course of action, through the continued pursuit of knowledge (science).-Abortion politics: requires a different kind of process of negotiation, and bargaining, in order to deal with conflicting values.
  • Higher grades + faster learning
  • Never study anything twice
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Discover Study Smart

How to determine what is fair

-context: in what context has the question of "a fair go" arisen? What is at stake for whom and why?
-relationships: who are the key stakeholders)? Are there any existing agreements, contracts or agreements between them?
-Time: what time constraints are we are facing? What trends over time we can observe and what are the implications of these trends now and in the future?

What is required in a fair process

-Impartiality. It respects the equality of moral values, democratic equality and the principles of natural justice.
-deliberative fairness is about how rules are set.
-transactional fairness is about how rules are operationalized and about playing the rules once set.
-transitional fairness requires reasonableness in how way rules are changed, regarding timing of policy implementation

How to assess fair outcomes

-Extent to which policies contribute to an increase in wellbeing and improvement in distribution of wellbeing
-Assess policies regarding the extent to which they actualise agreed set of values

Four values against which to assess fair outcomes:

-Freedom: distinction between negative and positive freedom.
oNegative freedom: once he policy is implemented, if it intrudes the liberty of the individual
oPositive freedom: does the policy enable people to pursue their own idea of the good.
-Equity is proportional equality in the distribution of costs and benefits.
oSocial recognition in terms of unequal needs, unequal talents and abilities
-efficiency: requires us to make the best us of available resources to as possible desired social ends.
-Reciprocity: means a complete life with opportunities to belong, participate and contribute according to our abilities

What is good policy advice

-Free: offer your best advice to decision makers, and don’t withhold key evidence or information.
-Frank: Be open and honest.
-full: bring all the available evidence and multiple perspectives
-Focused: on the outcomes the governments want to achieve
-Without Favour: provide politically neutral advice, that’s impartial to interest groups
-Fearless: be bold in striving for new ways of doing things
-fallible: advice and its underpinning evidence needs to be clear and testable
-Future focused: keep an eye on the future

The question on the page originate from the summary of the following study material:

  • A unique study and practice tool
  • Never study anything twice again
  • Get the grades you hope for
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Remember faster, study better. Scientifically proven.
Trustpilot Logo