Nation State - Major obstacles to nationhood e.g. provincialism and Protestantism

8 important questions on Nation State - Major obstacles to nationhood e.g. provincialism and Protestantism

What did the FWOR do in terms of effecting the monarchy and forging a nation state? Give two pieces of evidence.

- undermined the status of the crown

- ceased progress towards nationhood

e.g. The Catholic League (during the succession crises) - after the death of Anjou 1584 French Catholics were willing to look to the King of Spain (PII) for leadership & money rather than their own monarch = hardly a ringing endorsement of national unity

e.g. Huguenots called England and the Palatine for aid - foreign armies on Fr soil = no national identity 

What evidence is the to suggest territorial division at the beginning of the period?

In the Duchy of Bar (the eastern frontier of France) the Duke of Lorraine paid homage to the King for 1/2 his territory and 1/2 to the HRE

What evidence is their to suggest that provinces still clung onto their own traditions despite monarch's attempts to erode customary law and codify the legal system?

Failed Pancarte (1601)

Salic Law

  • Higher grades + faster learning
  • Never study anything twice
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Discover Study Smart

Why did a shared nation outlook not emerge?

The Italian Wars and the establishment of royal Gallicanism  caused resentment from the clergy (Concordat of Bologna)

Why might it be unsurprising that local interests were protected strongly?

Being part of a nation state arguably only meant an increase in taxes e.g. monarch intrusion through maitres de requetes 

What was the role of a provincial estate? Why does this undermine a nation state?

Uphold customs and liberties of that provence - more tightly defended in the second half

What is an obstacle regarding nationhood and provincialism?

Though a sign of continuity they held obstacles regarding taxes e.g. resistance of new taxes or extension of old ones e.g. the pancarte and the gabelle + the pays d'etats (most significant example) as they occurred in newly acquired territory. 

Why did religion undermine a nation state?

It was a catalyst for war, catholic league, calvinism + the Huguenot republic 

- the Catholic league and Huguenots had foreign support = dangerous - although HIV uses foreign intervention to promote a nation state when he declared war on Spain which united France against enemy. 

The question on the page originate from the summary of the following study material:

  • A unique study and practice tool
  • Never study anything twice again
  • Get the grades you hope for
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Remember faster, study better. Scientifically proven.
Trustpilot Logo