Governance and power

12 important questions on Governance and power

What characterizes a city?

(Gordon Childe, The Urban revolution (1950))
  1. Population density includes citizens that are not peasants
  1. concentration of agricultural surplus
  2. public buildings
  3. ruling class, that is different from the rest of the population
  4. skills: writing, use of wheel and plough
  5. other forms of science (astronomy, maths, etc)
  6. artistic expression
  7. long-distance trade
8. sense of community: identity, language, shared facilities

BUT, also contested
- too much focus on material
- too little on social relations

What were the models and opposition of East versus West and what was the result of this contesting?

- Elements of Oriental City (power and despotism) and Western City (freedom and citizenship) coexisting in both worlds.
- focus on globalization
- focus on non-Western research
- more comparative research

With as a result> two historical phases
1. Public buildings to serve power
2. Public buildings to serve the power AND the communitiy

How did the early city governance work?

Villages have only communal institutions

cities have also:
  • administrative and political institutions (palace, temple, castle)
  • a power that is not communal (; a result of inequality between people (elite, king, governor)
  • power of the leader and  community of citizens


two forms of public buildings in cities:
  1. seats of power
    1. seats of communal life
  • Higher grades + faster learning
  • Never study anything twice
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Discover Study Smart

What are the seats of power?

Public buildings for the basic functions of a government:
  • run by the central power
  • not or hardly accessible to common people

> palace, temple, public granaries and storehouses, tribunals (courts), fortifications.

What are the spaces of city community ?

Public buildings to serve the community :
  • organized by community members
  • widely accessible

> seats of public officials, place of the assembly, marketplace, public performances, care of the body, care of the Mind, water and garbage.

How the cities in pre-modern times governt 1500-1800?

Self-organization of the cities between 1500 -1800 related to economy

merchants became central to urban communities:
  1. the organisation of merchants guilds: regulation and protection trade
  2. prominent members of the urban elite
  3. member of the urban governance

throughout Europe and outside in Chinese and Ottoman Empires!
Level of autonomy different.  

Were there also public sphere outside Western world?

Yes, Waqfs Ottoman Empire, Teahouses in China > All social interaction

How is imagined communities expressed in urban communities?

  • Through buildings
  • rituals and shared events
  • Urban spaces
thus, not only in culture but also within cities

What are other types of distinction within cities?

  1. Ethnicity (colonial cities)
  2. religion (Ottoman Empire)
  3. Government and non-government (ottoman Empire)
  4. citizens with rights and inhabitants (Europe)
  5. respectable people and plebeians
  6. rich and poor
  7. deserving and undeserving

Civil Societies in Pre-modern Europe?

Non-governmental organizations and institutions of ctizens that serve interests of citizens

Was there in pre-modern time a civil society in China?

Debate: No urban citizenship> state controls> no voluntary associations that serve citizens?> no civil society?

What is the impact of modern state formation in Europe?

  • From urban citizenshiop to state citizenship
  • states are increasingly taking over public administration and services
  • urban autonomy diminished; tasks and responsibility (social care, poor relief, any kind of facilities used by civil societies now taken care of central governments and states that governt cities)
  • the end of urban associations ( e.g. Craftguilds)

The question on the page originate from the summary of the following study material:

  • A unique study and practice tool
  • Never study anything twice again
  • Get the grades you hope for
  • 100% sure, 100% understanding
Remember faster, study better. Scientifically proven.
Trustpilot Logo